Ace Young - you mean Ace Yummy!
Will Makar - could not have done that any better
Gedeon McKinney - Liked his energy.
Taylor Hicks - I like him. Can anyone really rock Levon? You know he'll be around for a while but will never make Idol.
What the hell was Sway doing?
And has Paula ever said a mean thing in her life? How can you live like that? Constructive criticism needs to be criticism as well as constructive.